The Fish Rots from the Head Down: Francesco Aquilini and the Canucks’ Self-Inflicted Collapse
There’s a saying in hockey — and in most organizations, really — that culture starts at the top. In Vancouver, that saying has never been more painfully relevant. The Vancouver Canucks have gone from a team that pushed the Edmonton Oilers to seven games in the 2024 playoffs, to finishing dead last in the NHL with a 25-49-8 record and 58 points — a total so bad that the second-worst team in the league, the Chicago Blackhawks, had 14 more points. This didn’t happen by accident. It happened by design. Or more accurately, by the lack of it.
The fingerprints of dysfunction are all over this organization, and most of them trace back to one man: owner Francesco Aquilini.
It’s not just a feeling fans have, or a hot take from the local sports radio crowd. The Athletic ranked Aquilini 31st out of 32 NHL owners in 2025, giving him a D+ grade. His two lowest scores were in treatment of the fan base — ranked 31st — and organizational stability, ranked 30th. The only owner ranked below him presides over the Buffalo Sabres, a franchise that hasn’t sniffed the playoffs since 2011. That’s the company Vancouver’s ownership is keeping. Yardbarker
What makes the Aquilini situation so maddening is that the pieces were there. Jim Rutherford, a three-time Stanley Cup champion, was brought in to right the ship. And for a while, it was working. Then came the decisions that only make sense if you understand who actually holds the pen in Vancouver. Reports emerged that there were at least three competing lists of GM candidates circulating within the organization — one from Rutherford, one from the business side, and one from ownership itself. In a functional NHL front office, the owner signs the checks and stays out of the way. In Vancouver, that line is, to put it generously, a creative interpretation. The Hockey Writers
Fans have described Aquilini as a fine owner when the team is winning, but someone who meddles and micromanages from behind the scenes when things go sideways — precisely when steady, clear leadership is needed most. And things have gone sideways in a spectacular fashion. During the 2025-26 season alone, the Canucks traded Quinn Hughes, Conor Garland, Kiefer Sherwood, Tyler Myers, David Kampf, and Lukas Reichel. That’s not a retool. That’s a yard sale. Vancouver CanucksHeavy Sports
The Quinn Hughes trade deserves its own moment of silence. Hughes — the 2024 Norris Trophy winner and the franchise’s all-time leading defenceman in scoring — was dealt to the Minnesota Wild for Marco Rossi, Liam Öhgren, Zeev Buium, and a 2026 first-round pick. Trading your captain and best player is sometimes necessary. Trading him while the organization can’t even agree on who should be running it is something else entirely. CBC News
The chaos didn’t start this season, either. It traces back to 2022, when Vancouver signed J.T. Miller to a seven-year deal — essentially choosing Miller over Bo Horvat, who was then traded to the Islanders the following January. What the organization reportedly knew, and chose to ignore, was a growing personal rift between Miller and Elias Pettersson. That problem festered for two full seasons before Miller was finally moved to New York. By then, the damage was done. ESPN
GM Patrik Allvin was fired in April after the team’s 25-49-8 season, and now the Canucks are conducting a GM search with Aquilini still holding significant sway over the final decision. The concern league-wide is that the search itself is compromised before it starts. The NHL is a small circle, and the stories about Vancouver’s management style have become league lore. Good candidates know what they’re walking into. Some will still take the job — there are only 32 of them in the world — but the best ones might not. House Of HockeyThe Hockey Writers
The Canucks have the bones of a rebuild: young pieces coming back in trades, a likely top-three pick in 2026, and Elias Pettersson still on the roster — for now. But none of that matters if the same ownership dynamic that turned a playoff contender into a 58-point disaster is still calling the shots from the shadows. Vancouver doesn’t need another retool. It doesn’t need another reset. It needs its owner to do the hardest thing an owner can do: step back, trust the people he hired, and let hockey people run a hockey team.
Until that happens, the Canucks will keep rearranging deck chairs — and Canucks fans will keep watching their team circle the drain with a renovated roster and the same old problem at the top.
The Add List + 🏒